The sports drinks conspiracy that kills

Gatorade.jpgIf you ever run a marathon, you will be bombarded with advice like this from the "Gatorade Sports Science Institute" (!):

Fuel up before the race-Drink at least 16 ounces of a sports drink with carbohydrates about 2 hours before the marathon, then another 8-16 ounces just before the race. Be sure to stop to drink at least 2-4 ounces at every fluid station.

Drink at every fluid station– Drink even if you don’t feel thirsty. Thirst is not a reliable indicator of fluid needs because by the time you feel thirsty, you’re already dehydrated.

Even the apparently impartial BBC tells us:

Take on plenty of water as you make your way to the starting area on Sunday morning and accept water and sports drinks every time they are offered during the race, even if you are not thirsty.

Is this good advice?  It is if you have shares in Gatorade (made by Pepsi) or Powerade (made by Coke). But it is increasingly apparent that it is NOT good advice for marathon runners.

A recent article in the New England Journal of Medicine reported that thirteen percent of runners in the 2002 Boston Marathon had hyponatremia, a deficiency of sodium in the bloodstream caused by drinking too much fluid.  This is not a new finding: Tim Noakes (a professor of sports science) published research twenty years ago showing that water intoxication is a risk in endurance events. In 2002, runners died of hyponatremia in both the Boston Marathon and the Marine Corps Marathon – and there are at least a dozen other examples of death during marathons from hyponatremia, and many more people who have been severely ill and at risk.  Your risk of drinking too much far exceeds the risk of drinking too little.

This is, of course, not what the manufacturers of sports drinks – who also sponsor many races – want to hear, or want you to believe.  But as Noakes points out, there is no evidence of damage from short term dehydration during races:

Everyone becomes dehydrated when they race … But I have not found one death in an athlete from dehydration in a competitive race in the whole history of running. Not one. Not even a case of illness.

In my 2002 book, Running for Fitness, I discussed the dangers of over-hydration (the first mainstream book on running to do so, as far as I know).  I noted that the recommendation of the Amercian College of Sports Medicine was to drink 600-1200 ml an hour but that "there is a danger that this may be too much for non-elite athletes who are running a marathon".  I did not mention that the American College of Sports Medicine is sponsored by, er, Gatorade.

Thankfully, the mainstream media are beginning to get it.  Yesterday’s New York Times reported that the participant handbook for runners in the New York City Marathon will say – for the first time ever – that runners should drink no more than eight ounces of water every 20 minutes. It is a huge advance that runners are being encouraged to set an upper, not a lower, limit on their drinking during races.

What about the risk that your performance will suffer if you are dehydrated?  The evidence for this is scant: in fact, it is striking that those who do best in marathons are often the most dehydrated at the end. 

I wouldn’t recommend this to less experienced runners, but I recently tried running a marathon (the San Francisco Marathon in August) without drinking or eating anything at all. Nothing passed my lips: nada.  All I had to drink that morning was one strong cup of black coffee.  I ran 3:05 without any tapering or preparation (in fact, I ran ten miles the day before as well) and felt fine.

Amby Burfoot, the editor of Runners’ World, says in the October 2005 edition that you should

drink when you thirsty, understanding that water, sugars, and electrolytes will help you to feel and perform your best. But don’t force yourself to drink.

Pepsi doesn’t want you to believe it, of course.  The "Gatorade Sports Science Institute" still says:

Although dehydration remains the primary challenge for the vast majority of athletes, hyponatremia should be recognized as a possible threat to those athletes who go overboard in their hydration practices.

Gradually, this information is reaching more runners, and fewer are suffering the effects of hyponatremia.  After the deaths in 2002, the number of people suffering from hyponatremia in the 2003 Boston marathon fell to 6 percent; and the London Marathon doctors are also reporting that the number of cases is coming down.

 

We have an uphill battle against the advertising and propaganda of the sports drink industry, and the powerful addictive qualities of sugar.

Sports drinks are useful, in moderation, during marathons because they replenish your blood sugar and slow down the depletion of your glycogen stores. When you do drink during a marathon, it is a good idea to drink a diluted sports drink (or just water with some sugar and salt in it) rather than plain water. But evolution has equipped you with a thirst mechanism for a reason.  Our ancestors who hunted in the hot sun for many hours did not force themselves to drink before they were thirsty, and nor should you. 

Read more about these runners who are the victims of the sports drink industry campaign to persuade you to drink too much: 

8 thoughts on “The sports drinks conspiracy that kills”

  1. From what I’ve understood you saying before the problem with hte sports drinks is not so much the liquid or the sugar but the lack of salt. Correct?

    Owen replies: Not exactly. It is mainly the excess liquid. Your stomach and blood become too dilute. When the blood is too dilute brain cells absorb too much water, which causes the brain to swell and the tissue to push against the skull and sometimes down the brain stem. It is the total osmolality that is at issue. Adding more salt would help; but (a) nobody would drink the stuff (which is already foul anyway) and (b) there is a limit on the rate you can absorb salt. The real problem is drinking too much fluid.

  2. Thank you for taking the time to present such research, when there’s little financial incentive for you to do so.

    Personally, I anticipate that sports drinks companies are going to try and convince me that I need more of their product than I actually do, and try to discount accordingly. I’m glad that you’ve confirmed that I’m right to follow my body instincts (don’t bother drinking if i’m not that thirsty) and also my mental instincts (that people shouldn’t consume as much of a product as the producer would like).

    But i’m sure there’s geniunely ignorant people who but pseuso-science, and the world is a better place for people that confront it.

  3. I’ve seen the example – of too much water – used to illustrate the point “the poison is the dose”. There were experiments on rats which let someone estimate the fatal dose/rate for humans.

  4. Hi Owen

    I too found your piece extremely interesting, particularly the news that the New York City Marathon are for the first time waring of the dangers of hyponatremia. However, surely some of their advice is ambivalent at best;

    drink at least 16 ounces of fluid one to two hours before the race

    and then

    drink another 16 ounces of fluid in the hour before the race

    So whilst they are suggesting that runners drink no more than 8 ounces every twenty minutes when running and to drink no more than they sweat (how would they know?) they are still suggesting that substantial quantities of liquid are necessary before the race.

    They then go on to say slightly later that runners shouldfavour sports drink that has some sodium in it, such as Gatorade Endurance Formula, over water, which has none. Gatorade are still getting their plug.

  5. my doughter told me to drink 3 leter of puere water every day but never said that the tea and other soucec is part pf the 3 letre can you advice me of how much water should i drink every day
    i don do any excesis at all
    just hose wark
    she said drink it even if you dont fill like it can you advice me thank you
    yours
    amien alshaby

  6. Hi Owen,

    I am about to run my first Marathon (Berlin) and am super excited about this. I am currently trying to gather as much

    knowledge on nutrition before, during and after the race and in my research I have learned that during a marathon it is not uncommon

    to serve tea during a race!!! Now I thought tea was in fact a dehydrating liquid and not necessarily something you want to drink during a race.

    What is your position on drinking tea during a race (pros and cons)?

    Great Blog by the way.

    Best regards

    Niels Cain Birkmose

     

     

     

  7. Niels

    I’m sorry to say that I have never seen any evidence about drinking tea in races.  My prejudice is that tea, being a diuretic, would not be the best drink you can use; but if you find it palatable then the benefits of drinking something you like might be sufficient to outweigh this. 

    Unsweetened tea contains no calories. Most marathoners will want to consume sports drink containing a source of energy.

    Owen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *